Advancements in diabetes Care in Poland
-
Copyright
© 2023 PRO MEDICINA Foundation, Published by PRO MEDICINA Foundation
User License
The journal provides published content under the terms of the Creative Commons 4.0 Attribution-International Non-Commercial Use (CC BY-NC 4.0) license.
Authors
Background: The aging
population and increasing prevalence of diabetes are placing significant strain
on healthcare systems globally, including in Poland. In recent years, notable
progress has been made in establishing patient care systems and improving
access to treatment, with significant changes in the reimbursement of
innovative therapies. However, as the impact of diabetes on the healthcare
system continues to grow and advancements are introduced in patient care, there
is a pressing need, to continually search for the most optimal solutions to
further enhance diabetes care.
Objectives: This paper summarize
developments of diabetes care in Poland with a special focus on reimbursement
of novel therapies introduced in recent 5 years.
Methods: We conducted
a review of published sources and publications on the management of diabetes
care in Poland. This included an analysis of the latest advancements in
coordinated care, the collaborative efforts between general practice physicians
and specialists, as well as changes in reimbursement policies and other notable
progressions in patient-centric care. Furthermore, we analyzed published
reports from the National Fund and assessed reimbursement expenditures.
Conclusion: The landscape
of diabetes treatment in Poland has undergone significant changes in recent years
driven by advancements in pharmacological therapies, technological innovations,
and healthcare policies. While challenges remain, these changes offer
opportunities for further progress in diabetes care in Poland. Continuous
efforts to improve patient centered care along with embracing emerging
technologies, will contribute to more effective diabetes management and
improved quality of life for individuals with diabetes in the country.
Introduction:
Diabetes is a
chronic, metabolic disease that affect about 557 million adults worldwide. Diabetes
can lead to wide range of health complications including heart disease, kidney
damage, nerve damage and blindness. It is one of major public health concerns
due to growing incidence and prevalence levels [1]. The same
trend has been observed in Poland. In 2018 2,9 million adults were treated for
diabetes in Poland, increasing from 2,5 million in just five years. The
incidence among adult population is on the level of ~300 k patients yearly,
slightly increasing mainly due to demographic structure [2].
Diabetes is
frequently referred to as a non-communicable pandemic. Over the years, various
initiatives have been implemented to address the increasing incidence of
diabetes and simultaneously improve health outcomes for patients. Managing
diabetes through achieving early and sustained glycemic control has
implications on individual patients’ health through lowering risk of micro and
macrovascular complication but also on large scale having impact on population
health and both direct and indirect costs [3]. Diabetes
treatment guidelines stress the benefits of patient centered approach to treatment,
starting from lifestyle measures notably exercise, body weight control and
healthy diet. As diabetes is a progressive disease when lifestyle interventions
are no longer effective in sustaining desired glycemic control pharmacological
therapies are introduced [4,5]. There are glucose-lowering
agents with multiple mode of actions available that can better target
individual patients’ needs and improve glycemic control [6-7]. In recent
years we have seen advancement in the use of telemedicine that can help with
education and monitoring in both life-style interventions and pharmacologic
treatment.
In this work
we analyze advancement in diabetes care in Poland introduced in the last five
years focusing on type 2 diabetes, the most prevalent form of diabetes in adult
population. We have started this analysis from the overview of epidemiology, in
the next step we have reviewed evolution of diabetes care in Poland focusing on
introduction of coordinated care including education,
telemedicine and monitoring. Lastly, we have reviewed advancements in
reimbursement of innovative pharmacological intervention.
Epidemiology
In the past epidemiology
estimations were based on prevalence data and extrapolations to general
population [3]. Advancements in electronic health
records have allowed for more precise estimations and publications based on National
Health Fund (NHF) data have presented actual number of diabetes patients
treated [8]. In the most recent report
published by NHF it has been reported that more than 2,9 million adults (9,1%
of adult population) were treated for diabetes in Poland. This number only
includes patients that have used NHF services related to diabetes treatment,
what means that this number includes only diagnosed patients. Diabetes
prevalence has increased by 13,7% between 2013 and 2018 and only half of this
growth can be explained by demographic factors. Additionally, there is a group
of patients that doesn’t receive required interventions, as in estimations from
2013 based on NHF and NATPOL data it has been reported that around ~20% of diabetes
patients are not diagnosed. Diabetes prevalence and incidence is clearly linked
with an aging society. Females aged 65-74 are the largest group of diabetes patients
(more than 500 thousands). Prevalence of diabetes increased with the age group
until the age of 85, reaching 30% for women [2].
Organization of diabetes care
Diabetes care in Poland is
delivered primarily in three types of health care settings – primary care
physicians (POZ), specialist care (AOS), and hospital setting [5]. In recent years Polish decision
makers have recognized the importance of patient-centered care and the
involvement of multidisciplinary healthcare teams in diabetes management.
Efforts have been made to enhance a collaboration between diabetologists, endocrinologists,
primary care physicians, diabetes educators, dieticians, and psychologists to
provide comprehensive care to individuals with diabetes. This multidisciplinary
approach should ensure a holistic management strategy that addresses not only
glycemic control but also the prevention and management of diabetes-related
complications, psychosocial support, and lifestyle modifications [4].
Graph 1 Patient in the center of health care system
Majority of adult diabetes
patients in Poland are treated in POZ. In 2018 1,8 million of diabetes patients
have been treated in primary care setting, specialized diabetes care (AOS) has
served 0,9 million patients and treatment in hospital setting has been used at
least once by 0,3 million patients in 2018 year [2]. The NHS has introduced numerous
initiatives to encourage management of type 2 diabetes on POZ level. In 2022
new coordinated diabetes care program has been introduced [9]. The coordinated care aim to
raise the standard of patient care not only by equipping primary health care
with new diagnostic tools, but above all by comprehensive education and both
pharmaceutical and non-pharmacological interventions. In the guidance of
diabetes care in POZ it is explicitly mentioned that the goal is to manage
diabetes by general practitioners (GP) [10]. There are exceptions where referral
to AOS is recommended: treatment of type 1 diabetes; other specific types of
diabetes; difficulty in determining the type of diabetes; diabetes in pregnancy
and in women planning to become pregnant; any type of diabetes in children and
adolescents. Indications for a diabetes consultation as part of coordinated
primary health care are: failure to achieve therapeutic goals (consultation
primarily to intensify insulin treatment); occurrence of complications of
pharmacotherapy; occurrence of comorbidities that make treatment difficult; the
occurrence of diabetes complications; other special situations. After the
consultation, it is determined whether the patient is to be further treated by
a primary care physician or should be under the care of a diabetologist. In coordinated care, consultations may take the form
of discussions between a general practitioner (GP) and a diabetologist, or
between a patient and a diabetologist. These consultations can also be
conducted through telemedicine. Patients,
supported by care coordinators are responsible for Individual Medical Care Plan
(IPOM). IPOM is set up by GP and should include the following recommendations: control
visits, control tests, educational advice (up to 6 a year), dietary
consultations (up to 3 per year); specialist consultations. Tailoring treatment
plans on GP level based on individual patient characteristics, individual
preferences, and comorbidities has a potential for optimal diabetes management
both from outcomes and cost perspectives. Coordinated diabetes care has a
potential to significantly improve the quality of care for patients with
diabetes. In the same time, by shifting well controlled patients from
outpatient clinics to POZ, it can facilitate access to diabetologists for
patients who require specialized care to better manage their disease. Successful
implementation depends on project execution and funding. Training should be
provided to all service providers: GP’s, nurses, educators and coordinators
from both medical and technical perspectives.
Education programs
Therapeutic education in diabetes
allows patients to be active participants in their own treatment with the aim
of improving their quality of life and therapeutic compliance, resulting in
reducing potential complications [11]. In recent years there has been
an increased emphasis on empowering individuals with diabetes through
education, enabling them to actively participate in their own care and make
informed decisions regarding their lifestyle and treatment. Diabetes
self-management education programs have been promoted to provide individuals
with the knowledge and skills necessary to effectively manage their diabetes.
These programs cover various aspects, including understanding the condition,
monitoring blood glucose levels, medication management, healthy eating,
physical activity, and coping with the psychosocial aspects of living with
diabetes. Diabetes education programs are often conducted by certified diabetes
educators and delivered through group classes or individual counseling
sessions. Concept of therapeutic education has been included in the coordinated
care, there are also initiatives organized by individual hospitals, patient
organizations and local governments focusing on different aspects of treatment
including life-style management.
Dietary modifications are a
cornerstone of diabetes management. Patient education initiatives in Poland
have focused on providing comprehensive nutritional guidance to individuals
with diabetes. This includes educating patients about carbohydrate counting,
portion control, meal planning, and making healthier food choices. Dietitians
and nutritionists play a vital role in delivering personalized dietary
counseling and helping patients understand the impact of different foods on
blood glucose levels. There are multiple options that have been introduced,
from on-line diet plans available on NHF site to telemedicine consultation organized
by national center of nutrition education [12].
Physical Activity Promotion:
Regular physical activity is essential for managing diabetes and maintaining
overall health. Patient education efforts have emphasized the benefits of
exercise and provided guidance on incorporating physical activity into daily
routines. Education sessions may cover the types of exercises suitable for
individuals with diabetes, the recommended duration and intensity of activity,
and strategies for overcoming barriers to physical activity. Additionally,
patients are encouraged to consult with healthcare professionals to develop
personalized exercise plans based on their fitness level and any associated
complications.
Medication Management: Patient
education initiatives aim to improve medication adherence and optimize
medication use. Individuals with diabetes receive education on the importance
of taking prescribed medications as directed, understanding the action and side
effects of their medications, and adhering to the prescribed treatment regimen.
Education also includes instructions on insulin administration techniques,
including insulin pens, syringes, and insulin pump usage, if applicable.
Blood Glucose Monitoring: Patient
education focuses on teaching individuals with diabetes how to monitor their
blood glucose levels effectively. This includes instructions on using glucose
meters, interpreting results, and understanding target ranges. Patients are
educated about the significance of regular monitoring, the impact of food,
exercise, and medications on blood glucose levels, and how to respond to hypo-
and hyperglycemic episodes [4]. In recent years, significant
advancements have been observed in this area, specifically with the
reimbursement of continuous glucose monitoring (CGM) and flash glucose
monitoring (FGM) in Poland since 2019. Initially, reimbursement was limited to
patients with type 1 diabetes. However, as of January 2023, the reimbursement
criteria have been significantly expanded to include other types of diabetes
that require intensive insulin treatment [13].
All the mentioned above areas of
medical education can be further enhanced by availability of dedicated apps [14]. There are multiple areas of patients’
education in diabetes, hence diabetes apps are especially popular accounting
for 15% of the total number of disease-specific apps in 2021 [15].
Pharmacotherapy
In recent years, Poland has
experienced the introduction of several new pharmacological therapies for
managing diabetes. Notably, new classes of antidiabetic medications, including
sodium-glucose co-transporter 2 (SGLT2) inhibitors and glucagon-like peptide-1
receptor agonists (GLP-1 RAs), have been approved and made available through
reimbursement schemes in open pharmacies since 2019. These medications have
demonstrated significant efficacy in lowering blood glucose levels and reducing
cardiovascular risks among patients with type 2 diabetes. Moreover, both SGLT2
inhibitors and GLP-1 RAs have shown positive effects on weight loss and pose a
low risk of hypoglycemia. [6]. The availability of these
therapies has expanded the treatment options and improved the management of
diabetes in Poland. Together with other available therapy options: metformin, sulfonylureas,
DPP-4 and insulin allowed for truly patient centric pharmacotherapy, as
physician has now broad array of treatment options that can tailor to
individual patients needs considering for example patient weight or/and
cardiovascular risk factors. Diabetes treatment guidance provide clear
recommendations and treatment algorithms that should be considered taking into
consideration glucose control and various risk factors.
Despite the expanded reimbursement
of innovative therapies and the growing prevalence of type 2 diabetes, the
expenditure on diabetes reimbursement has increased at a comparable rate to
other therapeutic areas. Particularly noteworthy is the significant growth
observed in 2022, as depicted in Figure 2, where spending rose by 13%. Insulins
contribute the most to the reimbursement costs, with spending exceeding 600
million PLN since 2018. Surprisingly, despite the availability of modern
insulins, the budget allocated to insulin reimbursement only experienced a
slight increase in 2022, reaching 651 million PLN compared to 648 million PLN
the previous year (Figure 2).
The primary drivers behind the
increased reimbursement expenditures in the last three years were the costs
associated with SGLT-2 inhibitors and GLP-1 receptor agonists, with 152 million
PLN and 75 million PLN spent on reimbursement in 2022, respectively (Figure 3).
However, these figures still represent relatively small proportions of the
total budget allocated for diabetes reimbursement.
Source: Calculation based on NHF
data
Source: Calculation based on NHF
data
Diabetes care – improvements
areas
Despite many advancements in
diabetes care described above, there are still several challenges that affect
patients and healthcare providers alike. One of the biggest challenges in
diabetes care is the waiting time for visit in the AOS setting. Diabetes
patient had to wait on average 7,4 months for a specialist visit what is 3 months
longer than average waiting time for specialist visit and almost 5 months increase
vs previous year[16] The shortage of diabetologists and the high demand
for their services contribute to these long waiting times, making it difficult
for patients to receive timely and specialized care. As discussed before decisions
makers plan to shift care to POZ setting to limit queues in AOS.
Another challenge is the
absence monitoring of well-defined quality care indicators for diabetes
management. Without proper monitoring and evaluation of quality care
indicators, it becomes challenging to assess the effectiveness of diabetes care
and identify areas for improvement. Digitalization of health care and
electronic health records especially on the POZ level could enable better validation
of quality of patients’ care. In patient centric health care patient education
is well emphasized, unfortunately despite introduction of coordinated care
there is a lack dedicated funding for diabetes nurses/educators. These
healthcare professionals play a crucial role in diabetes care by providing
education, support, and self-management training to patients.
Furthermore, there are still
limitations in the reimbursement of novel drugs for diabetes treatment compared
the approved indications and recommendations of diabetes associations. We have
observed major progress in recent years, however Poland is still one of the
countries with highest access gap described both by time to reimbursement and
level of reimbursement. Patients wait from the time of EMA approval, on average
more than 800 days for reimbursement. Additionally, only 35% of medicines
registered between 2018 and 2021 have received reimbursement in Poland and only
8% have full access without limitations [17]. Delayed and limited access can create barriers to
accessing the most effective and up-to-date treatments for patients with
diabetes. This discrepancy between guidelines and reimbursement can lead to
suboptimal treatment outcomes and hinder the progress of diabetes management.
By addressing these
challenges, the healthcare system can better meet the needs of individuals with
diabetes and improve their overall health outcomes.
Conclusions
The landscape of diabetes treatment in Poland has undergone significant changes in recent years, driven by advancements in pharmacological therapies, technological innovations, and healthcare policies. The integration of personalized medicine approaches, patient-centered care, and multidisciplinary healthcare teams has improved the management of diabetes. While challenges remain, these changes offer opportunities for further progress in diabetes care in Poland. Continuous efforts to improve patient centered care and well managed adoption of recently introduced coordinated care in POZ, along with embracing emerging technologies, will contribute to more effective diabetes management and improved quality of life for individuals with diabetes in Poland.
Notes:
all authors declare that there are no conflicts of interest.
all authors declare that this research did not receive any funding for the research.
IDF Diabetes Atlas [Internet]. 2021 [cited 2023 May 21]. Available from https://diabetesatlas.org/
NFZ o zdrowiu Cukrzyca [Internet]. 2019 [cited 2023 May 21]. Available from https://ezdrowie.gov.pl/portal/home/badania-i-dane/zdrowe-dane/raporty/nfz-o-zdrowiu-cukrzyca
J Leśniowska, A. Schubert, M. Wojna, I. Skrzekowska-Baran, M. Fedyna. Costs of diabetes and its complications in Poland. The European Journal of Health Economics. 2013
Standards of Care in Diabetes -2023 Diabetes Care Volume 46, Supplement 1, January 2023
Zalecenia kliniczne dotyczące postępowania u chorych na cukrzycę 2022 Stanowisko Polskiego Towarzystwa Diabetologicznego Curr Top Diabetes, 2022; 2 (1): 1–134
Bailey CJ Day C Treatment of type 2 diabetes: future approaches. Br Med Bull. 2018; 126: 123-137
Bailey CJ. The current drug treatment landscape for diabetes and perspectives for the future. Clin Pharmacol Ther 2015;98:170–84.
Topor-Madry R et. al Prevalence of diabetes in Poland: a combined analysis of national database Diabetic Medicine 2019; 36:10
Rozporządzenie Ministra Zdrowia z dnia 15 września 2022 r. zmieniające rozporządzenie w sprawie świadczeń gwarantowanych z zakresu podstawowej opieki zdrowotnej Dz.U. 2022 poz. 1965
Mastalerz-Migas A et. al. Wytyczne rozpoznawania i leczenia cukrzycy dla lekarzy rodzinnych Polskiego Towarzystwa Medycyny Rodzinnej, Kolegium Lekarzy Rodzinnych w Polsce i Polskiego Towarzystwa Diabetologicznego Lekarz POZ 4/2022
Golay et. al. Therapeutic education of diabetic patients Diabetes Metabolism 24:3
Diety NFZ [cited 2023 May 21]. Available from https://diety.nfz.gov.pl/plany-zywieniowe/cukrzyca)
Stanowisko Polskiego Towarzystwa Diabetologicznego we współpracy z Konsultantem Krajowym w dziedzinie diabetologii w sprawie refundacja systemów ciągłego monitorowania glikemii [cited 2023 May 21]. Available from https://ptdiab.pl/images/aktualnosci/StanowiskoPTDiKOnsultantaiMZ.pdf
Shan R Sarkar S Martin S Digital health technology and mobile devices for the management of diabetes mellitus: state of the art Diabetologia (2019) 62:877–887
Sherazi et al Functions of mHealth Diabetes Apps That Enable the Provision of Pharmaceutical Care: Criteria Development and Evaluation of Popular Apps Int J Environ Res Public Health. 2023 Jan; 20(1): 64.
BAROMETR WHC [cited 2023 June 05]. Available from: https://www.gov.pl/attachment/bb888f27-bc5f-478c-9def-bb1703c682d8
EFPIA Patients W.A.I.T Indicator 2022 Survey [Internet]. 2023 [cited 2023 June 05] https://www.efpia.eu/media/677311/efpia-patient-wait-indicator.pdf